Citigroup upgrades Manpower Staffing and Robert Half Staffing Jan 06 2010

SP500 P/E Ratio

"Citigroup analyst Ashwin Shirvaikar issued a bullish note on the staffing sector early Wednesday, raising ratings on Robert Half International Inc. and Manpower Inc. to buy from hold. He cited "improving signs in the temporary employment sector over the past several months" as well as "optimism on the long-term secular trends in the staffing market" for the moves."

Interesting call by Citigroup Research this morning. I agree that layoffs are steady declining with the latest data. However I am still cautious that valuations have gotten ahead of itself. I'm more concerned with the valuations as pointed out in prior posts of Manpower.

• - Manpower continues to trade at a very rich premium at 1.78 P/B. A price to book near one means value. Clearly the market and speculation from analyst believe that Manpower will return to its glory days such as the Citigroup's analyst boosting its price target to 69. As seen in the price chart MAN is trading above it normalized trading range. MAN has traded well above the growth period during expansion, besides the recent credit induced bubble in 2007. The analyst clearly believes that the economy will produce jobs at such a torrid pace that valuations will be fair. I think we have to remember that permanent jobs provide higher margins. Temporary positions do not provide the valuations that would prop up multiplies of close to 90+x earnings.
  
• - Manpower is trading at a clip of 90+x current p/e, 83x this year's earnings, and 52x next year's earnings. Compared to the SP500 and Nasdaq p/e ratio, Manpower (MAN) is significantly overvalued.
  
• - Revenue continues to be in a significant decline from its high of 2007. While debt levels have continued to rise. For this one reason alone I am a bit more positive on Robert Half (RHI) due to its very minimal debt. Any future shocks in the economy will hurt Manpower's cash flow, and cause another possible downgrade in its credit rating.
  
• - Challenges remain with health reform, higher taxes, quantitative easing of liquidity later this year will continue to crimp hiring by small businesses which produce well over 80% of the jobs in the US.
  
• - Manpower's largest market France has stated that they are looking to reduce their debt levels to the EU standard. The stimulus package that they have provided has provided a slight uptick in their GDP. However challenges remain with the continued contraction in the European markets, especially Eastern Europe.

And last but not least Manpower did warn during their 3Q conference call
that they have warned for their 4Q. Irrational exuberance continues in this
market while actual demand from consumers, and tight and inefficient credit
markets persist.

Manufacturing Up, Jobs Continues To Be Down

Unfortunate as production in the US picks up, jobs continues to be a sore spot for the economy. The following chart via Clusterstock continues to point to questions that I've had for Manpower (MAN) which is heavy in the manufacturing sector.

Jobless Recovery in 2010 - MF Global

Recently MF Global released a research note concerning the top ten trends in 2010. One of the trends was the premise of a jobless recovery.

The following is the investor note from MF Global:

"2010 will be characterized by a jobless recovery. MFGR sees the unemployment rate peaking at 10.5% and closing the year between 9.5% and 10%. The unemployment rates in EM and ASEAN counties should fall more steadily while it will likely increase in Europe. MFGR is expecting the latter as many of the stimulus programs initiated by European government included programs directed solely at hiring or preventing layoffs.

Out of a survey of 10 Euro-Zone countries, 8 employed labour activation measures. Many of these programs are set to expire in the new year. As employers are facing a lack luster recovery, the likelihood of a robust expansion in the labour markets sans government incentives is minimal. Furthermore, employers will likely be forced to cut back on labour as its costs up to the point have been subsidized.

On the US front, the outlook for taxes is murky and the healthcare initiative which will likely force all employers to provide care or pay a penalty will discourage the expansion of the labour force. Though the Obama administration is extending the capital gains holiday for small businesses, employers need to feel confident that their profit margins will not erode in the future due to tax increases in order to genuinely contribute to job growth. Moreover, budget shortfalls at the state and local government level will cap government hiring.

Globally speaking, there has been a significant increase in structural employment that is now part of the new normal. The collapse of the financial markets has led to a permanent shrinkage of the financial industry and the impending regulation will make financial innovation, a factor that does lead to job growth, very difficult. The manufacturing industry faces the same problem. Globalization will lead to the removal of manufacturing jobs in advance economies and cause a shortage of skilled labour forcing many to look to build other skill sets."

Source: MF Global

Manpower Robert Half Valuation

• For the past week there has been bullish sentiment again in the human resource, temp space.

Robert Half International (RHI) received upgrades and revisions to their expectations.

While Manpower (MAN) received an upgrade from Banc of America ML.

I'm a bit more cautious on the space especially with the run up for this past year. Although there has been an improvement in jobs lost; there continues to be an underlying problem in the global economy.

This growth has been fueled by government stimulus and not so much private sector demand. And the growth has been muted by recovery standards. The US for example revised their GDP growth for the 3Q down to 2.2%.

While employment survey after survey still speak to weak to flat growth for Q1 of 2010.

• Valuation alone I would avoid the space till there is more clarity that there will not be a double dip recession. With commercial mortgage and ARMS, debt, and continued restrained spending by the consumer, and depressed wage growth there will be significant challenges abound to job creation.

• Higher taxes in 2010 will be a certainty in the US. And that will depress consumer demand. The risk that this will further depress job creation with demand as slack as it is.

• Valuations have run up to the point where these human resource stocks must meet or blow out its numbers. Take for example Manpower (MAN). I have pointed out MAN due to its lofty valuations in comparison with its competitors.

1. Trading at close to 90x p/e, and on a normalized base close to 60x earnings. And this considering that they have had earnings that have declined with the growth implosion of 2007. I normally track the technology sector where growth is more attractive. Manpower is trading at multiple that are present for a technology company. Unfortunate the last growth that MAN has seen was back in 2007.

Department of Labor 2008 - 2018 Projections

The United States Department of Labor released their latest projection of what the future holds for US labor.

The labor force looks too decline as I've suggested. This just confirms that growth in the US will continue to decline unless something truly changes such as a competitive advantage, or technological advance helps the sagging growth in the US.

Also of note is the growth in the demographics such as the Hispanic population.

And where the growth in jobs are headed. Manufacturing and production seems to be on a steep decline.

The file can be downloaded through the following link (Please be aware this is a pdf file) :

http://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/ecopro.pdf

Staffing Valuations Manpower MAN Kelly Services KELYA Robert Half RHI

So I was looking at the valuations of staffing firms after the recent run up, and with the 3rd quarter results having been reported.

Please do your own research on the following equities.

Points taken that seems surprising amid the still weak conditions for hiring.

• Among the competition only three had positive earnings, this includes:

1. ComForce (CFS)


2. Manpower (MAN)


3. Robert Half International (RHI)

• Manpower (MAN) and Robert Half International (RHI) are trading at a significant premium to its enterprise value.

• RHI has looked more favorable during its recent quarter. As the data above states they have managed their long term debt levels, and actually have a positive return on assets & equity.

• MAN has continued to look like a balloon that is about to pop. On all metrics its stock has looked expensive. Trading on 86x earnings, market cap that exceed its enterprise value, heavy debt levels compared to its assets and equity, negative return on assets and equity. Margins also look weak compared to the rest of the sector.

As stated in prior posts the staffing sector continues to look fairly rich. RHI looks mildly attractive due to its cost control. While MAN still looks exceedingly rich in its valuations. It is trading as if it is a tech stock without the growth nor the cost control of its peers.

Feel free to chime in to create a discussion.

Unemployment trending down

Entering 2010 the U.S. unemployment rate is at 10%. Although I still find very limited prospects for hiring from most large corporations, and small businesses in the US I still expect the unemployment rate to trend down.

This is partly due to the Census entering the hiring juggernaut. The US government is expected to hire around 800,000 individuals that will bring the unemployment rate down. This will look positive on a short term viewpoint, however longer term unemployment will still be at historical levels.

There will also be increased churn among employees as they look for the economy to improve to switch companies. Rates of disgruntle have increased as hourly wages, and hours worked have been cut dramatically. Until capacity utilization reaches a peak or robust levels there will continue to be a weak demand for labour.